Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence
The first US appellate ruling on fair use for AI training: training on Westlaw headnotes to build a competitor is not fair use.
On Sep 29 2026 the Third Circuit (No. 25-2153, precedential) affirmed that ROSS Intelligence’s use of 2,243 Westlaw headnotes to train an AI legal-research tool, to build a competing product, was not fair use. It held the headnotes original enough to be copyrightable, found ROSS’s use commercial and only minimally transformative, and recognized a market for licensing text as AI training data. A law-firm summary calls it what “appears to be” the first federal appellate ruling on fair use in AI training. A footnote distinguishes systems that generate new expression, since ROSS’s tool only returns existing opinion passages, so the ruling’s reach into generative-AI cases is limited. It shapes the wider AI copyright fight.
Timeline
Every dated event in the wiki that involves Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence, newest first.
- US Court of Appeals, Third Circuit → ROSS Intelligence (Thomson Reuters v. ROSS)
Affirmed that training an AI tool on Westlaw headnotes to build a competing product is not fair use; a law-firm summary says it appears to be the first federal appellate ruling on fair use in AI training. Favors copyright holders; a footnote limits its reach to non-generative tools.
Sources: Haynes Boone, “Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use for ROSS's Copying of Westlaw Headnotes”; Law360; Mintz (MSK) alert; Patently-O
Connections
Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence and everything one link away. Drag to move, scroll to zoom, click a node to open it.Open in the full graph →
What links here
Legal action AI copyright litigation (2026)
Publication Law360
Sources
- Haynes Boone, “Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use for ROSS's Copying of Westlaw Headnotes”, Oct 2 2026