AI Wiki · Mediocre Security
Legal action

Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence

The first US appellate ruling on fair use for AI training: training on Westlaw headnotes to build a competitor is not fair use.

On Sep 29 2026 the Third Circuit (No. 25-2153, precedential) affirmed that ROSS Intelligence’s use of 2,243 Westlaw headnotes to train an AI legal-research tool, to build a competing product, was not fair use. It held the headnotes original enough to be copyrightable, found ROSS’s use commercial and only minimally transformative, and recognized a market for licensing text as AI training data. A law-firm summary calls it what “appears to be” the first federal appellate ruling on fair use in AI training. A footnote distinguishes systems that generate new expression, since ROSS’s tool only returns existing opinion passages, so the ruling’s reach into generative-AI cases is limited. It shapes the wider AI copyright fight.

Timeline

Every dated event in the wiki that involves Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence, newest first.

Connections

Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence and everything one link away. Drag to move, scroll to zoom, click a node to open it.Open in the full graph →

What links here

Legal action AI copyright litigation (2026)

Publication Law360

Sources

  1. Haynes Boone, “Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use for ROSS's Copying of Westlaw Headnotes”, Oct 2 2026